Migration

Should we move from SAP ECC to S/4HANA or to Dynamics 365?

Companies on SAP ECC should move to S/4HANA when SAP is woven into their industry processes, group mandates or partner ecosystem, and should consider Dynamics 365 Finance and Supply Chain Management when the move to S/4HANA would be a reimplementation anyway and the business runs on the Microsoft stack. The S/4HANA vs Dynamics 365 decision is not about which product is better in general. It is about which platform fits the company for the next decade, given that SAP ECC mainstream maintenance ends at the close of 2027 and almost every route forward involves real redesign.

For many midsize and upper midsize groups, the honest starting point is that staying with SAP is not automatically the cheaper or safer choice. A move to S/4HANA is a major programme in its own right, often comparable in effort to adopting a new ERP. Once that is accepted, the comparison becomes fair, and a credible SAP S/4HANA alternative deserves the same scrutiny as the default path.

Key facts at a glance:

• SAP deadline. Mainstream maintenance for SAP ECC 6.0 ends at the close of 2027, with extended maintenance to the end of 2030 at a higher fee.
• 2033 option. SAP's transition option for 2031 to 2033 is a cloud subscription with conditions, not an extension of on premises maintenance.
• Effort. Both S/4HANA greenfield projects and Dynamics 365 projects are reimplementations; only a system conversion keeps ECC history in place.
• Dynamics 365 fit. Strongest for midsize groups, subsidiaries and companies standardised on Microsoft 365, Azure and Power BI.
• S/4HANA fit. Strongest where SAP industry solutions, group wide SAP mandates or a deep SAP skills base already exist.
• Best first step. A comparative analysis of both paths before licences are bought, based on processes rather than vendor presentations.

‍

What do the SAP ECC deadlines really require?

SAP has confirmed that mainstream maintenance for SAP ERP 6.0, the core of ECC, ends at the close of 2027. Extended maintenance runs from 2028 to the end of 2030 at a premium on the maintenance basis, and in 2025 SAP added a transition option for 2031 to 2033. As The Register reported, SAP itself stresses that this option is not a prolongation of the 2020 deadlines and is not about extending on premises maintenance. According to SAPinsider's analysis of the conditions, it requires a move to SAP ERP private edition before the end of 2030, applies to large systems of at least 2 TB, and is paired with a separately charged success plan.

The practical reading is that 2027 is the date that matters for planning, not 2033. Extended maintenance buys time at a cost, and the 2033 option is aimed at very large, complex SAP estates that are already committed to SAP's cloud. For a midsize group, the choice in the next twelve to eighteen months is effectively a choice of platform for the following decade. Waiting for the last possible date mainly reduces the number of experienced consultants available, because thousands of ECC customers are making the same move at the same time, and the market for SAP and Dynamics specialists alike will tighten as the deadline approaches.

‍

__wf_reserved_inherit

S/4HANA vs Dynamics 365: how do the two paths compare?

Both platforms are mature, cloud capable ERP systems with strong finance, supply chain and manufacturing coverage, so the comparison is less about features and more about fit. S/4HANA keeps the SAP data model, terminology and skills a company already has, and a system conversion can carry configuration and history across, which is valuable for companies whose ECC design still matches how they work. Dynamics 365 Finance and Supply Chain Management starts from a different model, so it is always a new implementation, but it integrates natively with Microsoft 365, Teams, Power BI, Power Platform and Microsoft Fabric, and receives continuous updates rather than periodic upgrade projects.

Commercial models also differ. SAP steers new customers towards RISE with SAP, a bundled cloud subscription, while Dynamics 365 is licensed per user and per role, with lighter licences for occasional users. Neither model is cheaper in every case, but the Dynamics 365 approach tends to suit organisations with many occasional users and fewer heavy users. The table summarises the differences that most often decide the outcome. One point is often missed: the skills question. The pool of consultants who know both SAP finance and modern cloud delivery is under heavy demand as the 2027 date approaches, while Dynamics 365 skills are more widely available in midsize markets, which affects both day rates and the stability of the project team.

Criterion SAP S/4HANA Dynamics 365 Finance and Supply Chain
Migration effort from ECC System conversion possible; greenfield is a reimplementation Always a new implementation with data migration
History Can be kept in a conversion Balances, open items and selected history migrated; rest archived
Licensing RISE with SAP bundles and subscriptions Per user and per role, with lighter licences for occasional users
Ecosystem SAP Business Technology Platform and SAP partners Microsoft 365, Azure, Power Platform, Fabric and Power BI
Typical sweet spot Large enterprises and SAP centric industries Midsize and upper midsize groups and subsidiaries
Update model Release cycles managed with SAP Continuous updates from Microsoft several times a year

‍

When is Dynamics 365 the better SAP S/4HANA alternative?

Dynamics 365 tends to win when three conditions meet. The first is that the ECC system has drifted from how the business works, so a conversion would carry outdated design into S/4HANA and a redesign is needed anyway. The second is that the company already runs on Microsoft: Office, Teams, Azure and Power BI are its daily tools, and IT would rather manage one ecosystem than two. The third is scale. For groups with a few hundred ERP users and several subsidiaries, the cost and complexity of an S/4HANA programme can outweigh its benefits, while Dynamics 365 offers a broad standard scope with less overhead. Typical signals that point towards Dynamics 365:

• Redesign needed anyway. ECC is heavily customised or no longer matches the operating model.
• Microsoft first IT. Microsoft 365, Azure and Power BI are already the standard.
• Subsidiary or midsize scale. Hundreds rather than thousands of users, often across several countries.
• Skills market. Difficulty hiring or retaining SAP specialists at reasonable cost.
• Two tier option. A parent on SAP that is open to subsidiaries running Dynamics 365 with integrated consolidation.

The reverse also holds. Where SAP industry solutions run core operations, where a parent company mandates SAP across the group, or where the internal SAP team is large and capable, S/4HANA is usually the rational choice.

‍

What happens to SAP data and integrations in a move to Dynamics 365?

Moving from ECC to Dynamics 365 does not mean losing the SAP past. The usual approach is to migrate master data, opening balances, open items and a selected period of transactions, typically the current and previous financial year, and to keep older history in a searchable archive or a reporting database that finance and auditors can use without SAP. Master data is where most of the effort goes: customers, vendors, products, bills of materials and charts of accounts need to be cleansed and mapped, and this work is cheapest when it starts while ECC is still the live system.

Integrations follow a similar logic. Interfaces built around SAP IDocs or custom ABAP programs are rebuilt using Dynamics 365 data entities, APIs and Azure integration services, and each one is retested with the connected system. Companies with a large SAP footprint around the ERP, such as SAP warehouse, planning or HR solutions, need to decide early which of these stay and which move, because that decision shapes both scope and timeline. A phased approach often works best: one subsidiary or country goes first, proves the data and integration design, and the rest follow on a tested template, with lessons from the first wave built into every later one.

‍

What does each path cost?

Direct comparisons of S/4HANA migration cost and Dynamics 365 project cost are difficult because scope rarely matches, but the structure of the cost is similar. Services for design, build, data migration and testing form the largest line on both sides, followed by licences or subscriptions and internal time. For a midsize group, an S/4HANA greenfield or selective transition and a Dynamics 365 implementation of the same scope often sit in a comparable range for services, while the long term difference is driven by licensing model, the cost of specialists and how many extensions must be maintained through updates. Companies should be cautious with any comparison that prices only software, because services and internal effort usually exceed licences in the first three years.

The most reliable way to compare is to price the same scope twice: the same processes, entities, integrations and data, run through both platforms. That exercise often reveals that the deciding factors are not the headline prices but the number of customisations each path needs, the availability of consultants, and the cost of running the platform for ten years. It also forces the business to define its target processes before choosing software, which reduces risk whichever path is chosen. For a detailed view of timeline and budget on the Dynamics 365 side, see our guide to Dynamics 365 Finance and Operations implementation timeline and cost.

‍

__wf_reserved_inherit

How should the board frame the decision between S/4HANA and Dynamics 365?

The board should frame the ECC decision as a choice of operating platform for the next ten to fifteen years, not as an IT upgrade with a deadline. That framing changes the questions. Instead of asking which migration is quicker, directors ask which platform best supports the group's strategy: planned acquisitions, new countries, a shared service centre, a change in manufacturing footprint or a shift towards services. They ask which ecosystem the company's people already work in every day, and which one the IT team can realistically run and govern with the skills it has or can hire.

It also helps to separate the decisions that are reversible from those that are not. The choice of ERP platform is effectively irreversible for a decade. The choice of implementation partner, the sequence of countries and the depth of process redesign can be adjusted as the programme learns. Boards that spend their attention on the irreversible decision, and give clear principles for the reversible ones, avoid the common pattern in which a platform is chosen quickly under deadline pressure and the programme then spends years compensating for a poor fit. A short, structured comparison of both paths, with the same scope priced on each side, is the cheapest insurance against that outcome.

‍

What are the main risks on each path, and how are they controlled?

Each path carries its own characteristic risks. On the S/4HANA side, the main risk is carrying the past forward: a conversion that preserves ECC customisations and processes the business has outgrown, so that the new platform looks modern but behaves like the old one. Close behind it is resource risk, because the same experienced SAP consultants are being sought by thousands of ECC customers before 2027. On the Dynamics 365 side, the main risks are data and integration: years of SAP master data to cleanse and map, and interfaces built on IDocs or custom ABAP to rebuild. A further risk is organisational, as users who know SAP terminology learn a new system.

Both sets of risk can be controlled, and the controls are similar. A fit gap analysis against the target processes shows how much redesign each path really needs. Early data profiling, started while ECC is still live, exposes quality problems before they become cutover problems. A pilot entity or country proves the template before the rest of the group moves. And a clear rule on customisation, such as requiring a business case for every extension, keeps either platform close to standard. A partner that describes these controls in concrete terms for your company, rather than in general methodology slides, is giving you useful evidence about how the programme will actually be run.

‍

__wf_reserved_inherit

Which questions should you ask before committing to either platform?

Whichever direction the analysis points to, a short set of questions tests whether the decision is ready to be made. If the leadership team cannot answer them with confidence, the comparison needs more work before a platform is chosen:

• Which processes must change? A written list of target processes, agreed by the business, should exist before either platform is priced.
• What will ten years cost? Licences or subscriptions, partner services, internal staff and extension maintenance should be compared over the same period.
• Who will run the platform? The internal team, its skills and the support partner should be named for both options.
• How will history be kept? Auditors and finance should agree how older SAP data will be archived and accessed.
• What happens if the timeline slips? The cost and terms of SAP extended maintenance should be known as a fallback.

These questions are deliberately platform neutral. They do not favour SAP or Microsoft; they test whether the organisation knows what it wants the next platform to do and what it is prepared to spend over its life. Leadership teams that can answer them usually find that the platform choice becomes much clearer, and that the debate moves from vendor claims to the company's own priorities. Teams that cannot answer them should invest a few more weeks in the comparison, because the cost of that delay is small next to the cost of committing a decade of budget to the wrong platform.

‍

How ANEGIS helps SAP ECC customers decide

ANEGIS is a Microsoft Solutions Partner for Business Applications focused on Dynamics 365 Finance and Supply Chain Management, with 98 Dynamics 365 specialists and more than 170 experts in Poland and the UK. Its SAP ECC to Dynamics 365 migration service starts with a comparative environment analysis before any licence is bought, then supports the move in full or in stages, for example starting with selected subsidiaries or countries while the rest of the group stays on SAP for a period. Risk is managed at every step, from balance reconciliation to the go live contingency plan.

The platform ANEGIS proposes already runs complex groups. For TERG, the owner of the Media Expert chain, ANEGIS built one financial platform for 14 group companies and about 400 stores with more than 40 integration interfaces. For NCC, the Swedish construction group, the ANEGIS team develops modules and integrations on Dynamics 365 Finance and Operations, its main ERP. These projects show the scale at which Dynamics 365 is a credible alternative to S/4HANA. Where the comparative analysis shows that S/4HANA fits a client better, that conclusion is part of the result, because a recommendation that ignores fit would only move the risk into the project.

Compare both paths before you commit

The ECC decision deserves a side by side comparison based on your processes, not on vendor roadmaps. Contact ANEGIS to book a free consultation or a comparative analysis of S/4HANA and Dynamics 365 for your business.

‍

See more

Migration

Which company is best at migrating Dynamics AX to Dynamics 365? 8 partners compared

Read article
Text Link
Migration

Dynamics AX to Dynamics 365 migration cost: what drives the price

Read article
Text Link
Migration

Is it safe to keep running Dynamics AX 2012 after end of support?

Read article
Text Link
Back to all

Looking for a Microsoft partner? Let's talk about your project

Work with a team that has delivered implementations and projects for dozens of companies. Schedule an introductory call and see:

How to tailor Dynamics 365 to your company's processes, rather than the other way around

Which areas are worth automating to save time and reduce costs

Here is the step-by-step implementation process with Anegis: from analysis to post-launch support

Select a meeting time
Thank you for your message!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.